Home |From the Editor |Reprints |About Digital TV |Press |Contact Us
  Weekly Schedule
  Programming Highlights
  Show Reviews
  New Products
  Product Reviews
  Measurements
  Product Directory/Listing
  Video Games
  Common Questions
  Digital TV & HDTV
  TV Technologies
  Audio
  Glossary
  Manufacturer Listing
  Advertiser Listing
  Reviewer Bios
  Current Issue
  Back Issues
  Reprints
Submit
  Take a Survey
Help us get to know you
better by participating in
our demographic survey!
/ Home / Products / Product Reviews /
 Deathmatch

 
 Toshiba SDP7000 vs. LG KU-17WDVD vs. Mintek DTV-233
 Dyson Speer
 03/01/2005


Video Performance – LG KU-17WDVD  
The brightness of the LG KU-17WDVD’s screen is good and has almost no hot spotting. Unfortunately, the gray scale tracking is the poorest of the three, and the grays in the image continues to appear slightly purple no matter how the picture settings (including the individual RGB controls) are adjusted. When playing a DVD, the edge definition is not as sharp as on the Toshiba set—but better than the Mintek—especially with lateral movement in the picture. On-screen graphics, however, are good and the set exhibits the best overall color palette when used with a PC.
Winner: Toshiba

Look and Feel – LG KU-17WDVD  
The most outstanding aspect of the KU-17WDVD is its classy, metallic remote control. This fine example of the remote control maker’s art features an intuitive layout of large, easy-to-press buttons. A sliding cover hides the less-used controls, while the convenient DVD eject button is out in the open near the top of the remote. There’s a small carrying handle on the back of the set and a cover to conceal the connecting cables. The side-mounted DVD controls are marginally easier to get to than the other two set’s top-mounted controls.   
Winner: LG

Features – LG KU-17WDVD  
Several nice features help the KU-17WDVD give the Mintek DTV-233 (see next page) a run for its money. The KU-17WDVD is the only model to include PIP, or picture-in-picture (plus POP and side-by-side dual screens) capability in addition to individual control of the “red,” “green,” and “blue” picture settings. Like the Toshiba SDP7000, the KU-17WDVD has a five-band audio EQ and automatically selects the DVD input when a disc is inserted in the side-mounted slot. Of the three, the KU-17WDVD‘s stand has the most swivel and tilt range. The presence of an eject button for the DVD player on the  remote is a mandatory feature since the chassis-mounted disc controls were near impossible to find and operate unless you’re leaning over the TV.  
Winner: (tie) Mintek & LG

Audio Performance – LG KU-17WDVD  
Here’s a quick, succinct description of the  KU-17WDVD’s audio performance: decent clock radio sound. With its five-band equalizer set flat, the bass response is weak and thin. On the preprogrammed “music” setting, the bass gets a little tubby and bloated. Even after adjusting the EQ for best output, the sound is acceptable but not great; in other words, although the KU-17WDVD plays CDs, you probably won’t utilize that aspect.
Winner: Toshiba

LG KU-17WDVD, $1,199.95
www.lgusa.com; 800.243.0000
RATING: SOLID

 
1 | 2 | 3 | >>
Printer Friendly Version   Email a Friend
GET THE NEW ISSUE! FREE S&H

Poll
Newsletter
Digital TV Magazine Updates
Enter your email address to subscribe now!