Home |From the Editor |Reprints |About Digital TV |Press |Contact Us
  Weekly Schedule
  Programming Highlights
  Show Reviews
  New Products
  Product Reviews
  Measurements
  Product Directory/Listing
  Video Games
  Common Questions
  Digital TV & HDTV
  TV Technologies
  Audio
  Glossary
  Manufacturer Listing
  Advertiser Listing
  Reviewer Bios
  Current Issue
  Back Issues
  Reprints
Submit
  Take a Survey
Help us get to know you
better by participating in
our demographic survey!
/ Home / Products / Product Reviews /
 Product Review

 
 On-Wall Speakers From RBH, Klipsch, and BG
 Michael Trei
 12/01/2005


Rockin’ Ribbon 
Tweeters using a thin metal ribbon have been around for decades, but can they stand up to the demands of today’s listening habits?
Ribbon tweeters have always been kind of like the loudspeaker equivalent of a butterfly. Beautiful, yet fragile in the extreme. Typically, they have been most popular with those who value quality over quantity, where letting it rip might involve winding up the volume a bit during the finale of Beethoven’s Ninth, rather than trying to make our ears bleed while watching 2 Fast 2 Furious.

BG Corp, the speaker company formerly known as Bohlender-Graebener, uses ribbon tweeters to produce high frequencies. Ribbon drivers are known for their quality, not quantity, meaning they sound great but don’t play loud.
A driver, like a ribbon, that is much taller than it is wide is usually called a line source, and in the case of the BG R-17i we have a tweeter ribbon that is about 2 inches long, but less than a half inch wide. Tweeters will start to exhibit limited dispersion when they become larger than about an inch in any dimension, and a line source like the BG ribbon will have excellent dispersion across its short dimension, but will be quite directional above and below the longer axis. Designers will take advantage of this phenomenon to create a speaker that can cover a wide lateral range of seating locations, yet deliberately restricts the amount of high-frequency energy reflecting off of the floor and ceiling. In other words, this means that a ribbon tweeter can reduce the contribution of the room to the sound, resulting in clearer, less muddled music and movie effects.

Because of this unusual directionality, the ribbon tweeter in the R-17i can rotate 90 degrees, should you plan to mount the speaker on its side for use as a center channel. Flanking the ribbon is a pair of 4-inch woofers, followed by a pair of 4-inch passive radiators. Covering everything is a semicircular perforated silver (black is an option) metal grille––resulting in a wall-mounted R-17i looking a bit like a half section from some futuristic piece of pipe.

 
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | >>
Printer Friendly Version   Email a Friend
GET THE NEW ISSUE! FREE S&H

Poll
Newsletter
Digital TV Magazine Updates
Enter your email address to subscribe now!